Descendents of Floyd & Grace Lytle

Ken Thompson's Unofficial Medicine Lodge Website

This page is devoted to stories about things that happened in the Gyp Hills. Some of them may be true and some of them may not be true. You be the judge.

Table of Contents

  1. Talking with William
  2. There ain't no gold in them Gyp Hills
  3. The Early Dwellings at the Medicine River Read this story first to understand the story about the Cavalry.
  4. The Cavalry comes to town
  5. The Great Blizzard of '71
  6. The Day Muck-Muck Got His Wish
  7. Deacon Jim
  8. How Willie the Cripple Got His Nickname
  9. The Chestnut Mare

This Week's Episode:

Medicine Lodge Needs Buffalo Bill!

A short story by

Norman E. Thompson

Dean Stanton pulled on the reins to lead his buggy up to the hitchin' post in front of the bank. Just then the mayor of Medicine Lodge opened the door.

"Hey, mayor, did you see all them buffalo up north? There must be 3 or 4 hunnerd of 'em!"

The mayor turned around in his tracks. "Oh my Lord! They're not coming this way are they?"

"They's grazin' up around Isabel. Look'd like they trampled a corn field, what I saw of 'em. I was up to Isabel to talk to the blacksmith and stopped in at the barbershop. The barbershop was full of people talkin' cause ever'body is skeered they's gonna trample all their crops!"

Dean was interrupted when Willie the Cripple rode up on his paint. His name was Willie Johnson but everybody called him Willie the Cripple because he got shot in the foot and walked with a limp. "Hey Mr. Mayor, them buffalo has trampled my wheat crop! Dam, I worked all spring waterin' and pullin' weeds and now it's all fit for horse feed. Now how am I supposed to make some bread for this winter?"

"I don't know, Willie. I can't help you. But I'll go talk to the sheriff about that buffalo herd," the mayor said as he scratched his head and walked off towards the saloon.

"Come on, Willie. Let's go see if they'll do anything!" Dean Stanton told Willie as he flipped the reins to get his horse to go.

The mayor knew he'd have better luck looking in the saloon than looking in the jailhouse for the sheriff. He pushed open the saloon doors and saw the sheriff and a bunch of men setting around a poker table. "Are ya startin' up a game a poker?" the mayor said. Behind him came Dean Stanton and Willie the Cripple.

"Naw, we're just looking at this new gun," the sheriff said.

"It's a genuine Samuel Colt .45 caliber! I just bought her in Wichita yesterday! Ain't she a beauty!" Nort Williams said with a big grin on his face. The air was full of the smell of oil and blueing chemicals. "I ain't shot it yet so I don't know how true the barrel is. I'll have to do some target practice to figger out how she shoots. She's big enough to stop a bear! "

"Well maybe with all 6 rounds!" Willie the Cripple said.

"I hate to break up all your fun but we got a problem," the mayor said. "There's a big herd of buffalo up towards Isabel and they're tramplin' all the crops."

"Must be 3 or 4 hunnerd of 'em," Dean Stanton nodded as he told the sheriff.

"Dam. Anybody got any of them buffalo rifles?" the sheriff said.

"You mean like what Buffalo Bill Cody shoots 'em with?" Nort Williams asked as he put his new Colt .45 in his holster.

"We better put together a scouting party and go get a good look at 'em first," the sheriff said. "You said they're around Isabel?"

"They's trampling my wheat crop right now!" Willie the Cripple said.

"Well, Willie, I'm sorry about that. Looks like you'll have to eat buffalo meat instead of bread this winter," the sheriff said. All the men broke out laughing and the sheriff gave Willie a pat on the back.

"Sheriff, I heard Buffalo Bill is up at Ft. Zarah. Can't you send him one of those telegrams and maybe he'd come down here and shoot some of them buffalo for us," the mayor said.

"Well, sure, if you think he's at Ft. Zarah and you can get him here in time to help out before the buffalo do any damage. It's about a 3 day ride on a good horse from Ft. Zarah," the sheriff nodded to the mayor.

The mayor pushed open the saloon doors and walked off towards the Western Union office while the other men got on their horses. "Hey, daddy, can I go along?" Nort's son yelled out.

"Yeah, but stay out of trouble," Nort said ask the men mounted up and rode north.

Over at the Western Union office the mayor made out a message that said, "Send help. Medicine Lodge needs Buffalo Bill" and told the telegraph operator to send it to Ft. Zarah.


About an hour later the men came over a ridge and spotted the herd of buffalo. "Let's just stop here. I don't want to spook them," the sheriff said. "There must be hundreds of them." The men could see buffalo as far as the eye could see.

"I can just make out my cabin from here and it looks like my wheat field is full of buffalo," Willie the Cripple said.

"There's too many of 'em for us to handle," the sheriff explained to the men. "We're gonna go back to town and get as many men as possible. We gotta have as many rifles and cases of bullets as we can get. It's gonna take 2 or 3 rounds or more to stop one buffalo. I hope they'll just stay here grazin' while we get everything together. Then we'll come back tomorrow with some men and rifles. I kinda hope the mayor does send that telegram to Buffalo Bill. He'd sure know what to do to stop 'em."


When the men got back to town, the mayor was setting on a chair out front of the jailhouse. "I got that telegram sent off to Buffalo Bill but we ain't heard back yet," the mayor yelled to the sheriff.

The sheriff got off his horse and tied the reins up around the hitchin' post. "There was buffalo as far as we could see. Must be hundreds of 'em. We gotta stop 'em or they'll trample every crop in the county." While the sheriff explained his plan to the mayor, the other men went off to recruit more men for the buffalo hunting party. Nort and his son rode off towards their homestead.

Nort had a some good rifles at home that he thought were big enough to stop a buffalo. "Go unsaddle the horses. We're gonna take that case of rounds in the back of the buggy tomorrow," Nort told his son. His son led the horses over to the tack shed and got to work. Nort went inside the house and told his wife about the herd of buffalo. He put his new Colt .45 on the mantle over the fireplace in the front room, next to his hunting knives. Then in the bedroom he picked up his reliable .38 and put it in his holster. He knew that .38 would shoot straight and true. That Colt .45 would have to wait until he could shoot it enough to get the feel of it.

He kept his rifles in a rack on the wall. There were many a coyote and even some wolves that he stopped with these rifles. Nort remembered a few years back when he took his rifles to Wichita and had the barrels trued up. They were now the most accurate rifles he had ever shot. But then, he laughed to himself, he had never shot any of Buffalo Bill's rifles.

Over in the corner of the room, he had about half a case of .38 rounds left for his six-shooter. And next to that he had 2 cases of rounds for his .22 rifles. He picked up a case of bullets and carried it out to the buggy. Then a few minutes later, he came back in for the next case, and carried it out to the buggy. After two more trips, all his bullets were stowed in the back of the buggy. About that time, his wife yelled that supper was ready. He grabbed an armload of firewood from behind the tack shed and carried it into the house. The horses were put away for the night and he could make out the evening star in the sky. There was a full moon coming up in the east.


Nort's son tossed and turned in his bed. He was excited. He wanted to shoot a buffalo but he knew his dad wouldn't let him. His dad would tell him to stay out of trouble and probably make him load rifles instead of shooting. The full moon shone in his window. He could hear his dad snoring in the other bedroom.

He couldn't take it anymore. He got up, pulled his pants on and buttoned his shirt. He carried his boots so he wouldn't wake up his mom and dad. At least out on the front porch he could listen to the coyotes and watch the full moon, instead of tossing and turning in his bed.

As he went through the front room, he went over to the fireplace to throw a log on. As he looked up he saw his dad's new Colt .45 on the mantle. He picked it up and snuck outside to the front porch. In the light of the full moon he could see all the details of the gun. He checked to see if it was loaded. Nothing. His dad was too careful. So he stood there by the light of the full moon, playing fast draw with the Colt revolver. It was fun, but he knew he better be quiet so he wouldn't wake up his mom and dad.

He felt a twitch in his nose and woke up. It was cold and he was starting to shake. He looked up and the full moon was two thirds of the way across the sky. How long had he been sleeping in the chair on the front porch, he wondered to himself. He looked down and saw the Colt .45 on the floor. Luckily he could still hear his dad snoring. He picked up the gun and his boots and crept quietly back into the house. He put the gun back on the mantle next to the hunting knives, and noticed there was a box of rounds there too. The box said .45 caliber. He grabbed a handful of rounds and put them in his pocket. Then he snuck into his room and got into bed.


"Come on, git up, son! You're sleeping like you been out carousin' all night long!" Nort said as he shook his son. The boy opened his eyes and could see a little light outside. "We better git goin' if we're gonna git in that buffalo huntin' party."

Nort's son got dressed and went in the front room. He could see his mother putting some bacon and eggs on the table. His dad was already eating. He sat down and ate as if he was up all night long.

Outside, Nort and his son started hitching the horses up to the buggy. "Hey, son, I almost forgot my hunting knives. We may have a bunch of buffalo to skin and bring home some buffalo meat. Run inside and grab my hunting knives off the mantle. Go grab one of the saddle bags and put the knives in it, I don't want those knives gettin' lost."

The boy did as he was told, and ran inside the house with the saddle bag. At the mantle, he saw the Colt .45 and couldn't resist the temptation. He tossed it in the bag with the knives, and ran outside, and stowed the saddle bag full of knives under the seat of the buggy.

"We better git goin' if we're gonna make it there by daybreak," Nort said as his son climbed into the buggy.

"Daddy, can I shoot a buffalo?"

"No, you're gonna load the rifles for me."


As Nort and his son pulled the buggy onto Main Street of Medicine Lodge they could see a huge crowd in front of the jailhouse. There were men on horses, with 2 or 3 rifles in the saddles. There were several buggies with cases of bullets loaded in the back and long wooden crates of more rifles.

"Nort, where ya been? We been waitin' for you. You been out playing fast draw all night with that new gun?" Dean Stanton yelled when he saw Nort pull up to the crowd.

"We better git goin'," the sheriff yelled to the crowd.

They rode for about half an hour going north-northeast towards Isabel on the old Ridge Road trail. At about 5 miles they could start making out buffalo. It was a huge herd, the biggest anybody in Medicine Lodge had ever seen. As they got closer, the sheriff realized just how big their problem was going to be.

"This is a bigger herd than that one I saw in Deadwood back ten years ago," the mayor said to the sheriff.

"I never knew you went to Deadwood. Was you playing poker or minin'?" the sheriff asked.

"Well, yeah, it scared the hell out of me. I was playing poker and won the hand with two black aces and two black eights. A gun went off out in the street and I jumped about a foot out of my chair. I grabbed my money and left Deadwood and ain't been back since!" the mayor said. The sheriff laughed.

As the last of the buggies pulled up, the sheriff turned his horse around so he could give instructions to the men. "Now, spread out along this ridge so we can make a wall of rifles. Once we start shootin' the noise ought to scare 'em in the other direction so they don't go towards town. Wait until I shoot first!"

Slowly the buggies pulled out, and made their way along the ridge. The men on horseback dismounted and found a good spot with a tree or some cover, and laid out their rifles and ammunition on the ground. The men in buggies spread out evenly along the ridge. They formed a wall of firepower about a mile long.

Nort and his son found a spot in some trees, only about 20 yards from the leading edge of the herd of buffalo. The buffalo just grazed on the grass while Nort tied his horses to a branch of the tree and unloaded a box of bullets. He checked each rifle to make sure it was loaded, then laid it out in order on the ground.

As he carried the last box of bullets, Nort's son could see that saddle bag with the knives and the Colt .45 in it. He put the box of bullets down by the rifles. His dad was busy with the rifles. The boy ran back to the buggy, and grabbed the saddle bag. He quickly reached inside and pulled out the Colt .45. He reached in his pocket and pulled out the bullets. He popped open the bullet chamber and carefully put each bullet in. He had seen his dad do it dozens of times and knew exactly what to do. He clicked the bullet chamber shut and looked at the gun. And he took off running.

His dad looked up and didn't have the slightest idea what was about to happen. The boy ran right out towards the buffalo, yelling, "I'm gonna shoot me a buffalo!" He tripped on a big rock, fell head first into the dirt, and the Colt .45 went off with a loud boom. A big cloud of bluish gray smoke went straight up in the air. That was the loudest boom he had ever heard. Even the trees shook. And the herd of buffalo took off running. And they went in the direction of Medicine Lodge, not away from the noise like the sheriff thought they would.

As the buffalo closest to Nort started running, the other buffalo started running and following. It was like mob mentality. When each buffalo saw the others running, it started running too.

"Stampede!" the sheriff yelled. But that didn't help much. The men grabbed their rifles and started shooting, and a few buffalo fell to the ground. But dozens and dozens stampeded right past the men, following the leading buffalo, who were following the old Ridge Road trail. The mayor could see a cloud of dust coming off the trail.

"Anybody hurt?" the sheriff yelled. A few men ran over to pull a buggy upright, one that was knocked over by a buffalo.

"Dam you," Nort said as he took his hat and used it to beat his son over the head with. The sheriff laughed. The boy got up, still holding the Colt .45 in his hand, and started running to the buggy, with Nort running behind, yelling, cursing and waving his hat and arms in the air.

"Anybody who's not hurt, we better get to town and head off the stampede," the sheriff yelled out new instructions to the men.


Anna Mae Jones felt the ground shaking as she stood on the plank sidewalk in front of the bank. "What is it, an earthquake?" she yelled.

Molly Finch, standing on the plank sidewalk across the street in front of the post office, yelled out, "What's that cloud of dust?"

John Barber's horse, the only palomino in town, reared up on his hind legs, breaking the reins from the hitching post. It ran off down the street. All up and down Main Street, horses reared up and broke the reins, and ran off down the street. There was only 1 horse with a buggy behind it, tied to the hitching post in front of the saloon. It reared up, broke the reins, and ran off down the street with the buggy running wildly behind.

Then the first buffalo came into Main Street. Then the second, then a few more, and a few more, until Main Street was full of buffalo, stampeding.

Anna Mae Jones shrieked and cried as she held on to the post holding up the porch roof over the front of the bank. Molly Finch ran inside the post office and slammed the door behind her, breaking out the glass.

In front of the hotel, there was a buggy without a horse. The leading buffalo slammed into it, and knocked it clear over on its top.

Mac Reynolds, the town drunk, opened the swinging doors and looked out. A big buffalo ran up on the plank sidewalk, through the swinging doors, knocking Mac to the side. The buffalo ran through knocking over everything in its path, and flew through the big window, breaking all the glass, and back outside. Mac picked up his bottle of whiskey off the floor, and looked at it, and said, "I ain't never drinkin' no more never again."

Out on Main Street, the dust was so thick you couldn't see more than a few feet. The ground shook like an earthquake. Anna Mae Jones was shrieking but you couldn't hear her because of the noise.

The Postmaster stuck his rifle out the broken window of the door of the post office, took aim, and fired. His bullet knocked the buffalo down, and another four buffalo following it fell as they tripped over the body. The Postmaster's mouth dropped wide open as he looked at that pile of 5 buffalo! "Damnedest thing I ever seen!" he said to Molly Finch, who was crouched behind the counter of the stamp window. "'Scuse my language, mam," he said politely, but she wasn't worried about language at the moment.

At the corner of Main and Kansas Avenue, the buffalo turned down Kansas Avenue, stampeding past Victorian houses with white picket fences. Little girls playing on the grass with their dolls screamed and ran inside the house to their mothers. The ground shook while the cloud of dust covered the white Victorian houses with red dust. One brave little boy held up his toy pistol, carved from the branch of a tree, and shot the buffalo as they passed, saying "Bang! Bang! Bang!" His mother, just as brave, cried out his name as she ran out the front door, screen door slamming, and picked up her little boy and carried him back up the stairs to safety inside the house.

As the leading buffalo came to the creek at the west end of Kansas Avenue, they went for the creek instead of the one-lane bridge. That creek was deep with steep sides, and as the buffalo ran in, they fell. As each following buffalo ran up to the creek, it would jump right in, trying to jump the creek. But the creek was too wide, and the buffalo would fall to the bottom, breaking legs as they landed in the red mud at the bottom. Soon the creek filled up with dying buffalo.

After what seemed like an hour, the ground stopped shaking and the dust cleared. The Postmaster said, "Damnedest thing I ever seen!" as Molly Finch came out from behind the counter, shaking, but curious. She looked out on the street to see piles of buffalo, flailing their legs to get up, but prevented from getting up by their own broken limbs too weak to move their bodies. Up and down Main Street, there were piles of buffalo 3 and 4 bodies high. Molly Finch looked across the street to see Ana Mae Jones crying and shrieking, "my dress, I ripped my new dress". Down the street at the saloon, the doors swung open as Mac Reynolds staggered out, down the steps, towards a pile of 3 buffalo. He walked right into the buffalo and fell face first, adding his body to the top of the pile.

Just then the buffalo hunting party rode into town with the sheriff in the lead and the mayor right behind. "Oh my Lord," the sheriff said.

"Dear God, I ain't never!" the mayor said.

The door to the telegraph office opened, and out came running a man all dressed up in his Western Union uniform. "Mr. Mayor, here's that telegram you wanted. It's from Buffalo Bill, and say's he can't come 'cause he's got to go to Isabel to stop a huge herd of buffalo from tramplin' the crops!"



Click here to return to the home page.

Contact webmaster
Updated 11/11/08